Very nice niche tuck away on Staten Island,Food excellent.,service very amicable and professional staff was on point,Ambiance very very nice

So lovely, walking distance from home, by the coast and the best seafood on the Island. Lucky Tottenville!

Dishes are amazing !!! Service always on point Outdoor seating ... ps no credit card fees

I went to the Coral Bay Cafe for the first time yesterday and was very pleased with the service and the food as well as the location by the water. I was surprised to read some of the negative reviews because my party and enjoyed our meal and would go back again.

Food - very good service / great. only complaint - Small Soda was $4.00 per glass.... loaded with ice ....and NO FREE REFILLS. All restaurants give free refills , especially at those prices .

The restaurant looks exactly like it did before sandy! Great family, great staff. If you are looking for fresh fish this is your spot! The coral bay shrimp is something you will not find anywhere else. Again fresh fish, Alaskan king crab legs, oysters, clams and can't go wrong with lobster! I wish you had a view of the water, would make it the top notch summer spot. The only thing that's rough was parking, they have a small parking lot but since it is a residential street with a lot of homes parking was very tough. It wasn't super expensive but prices are up there. Will definitely return on a nice warm day.

Absolute gem!! haven't been to this restaurant since before super storm Sandy, as they were basically devastated and just reopened a year or so ago, so happy we found them again. Food is superb & the service was wonderful! Extensive menu! Kimberly and Jacob are second to none! Awesome local spot! highly recommend this restaurant if you're looking for excellent food, great service and just an enjoyable time all around!!